RealGM

REGULAR SEASON THREAD!!!!111

And I will look over these guys. Nice to see we're adding the top player in the class and a catcher at that.

Love the organizations' emphasis on the catcher position and making sure we continue to draft and develop them.

Ranma, you need to be on a payroll for some team's scouting department. I can help you evaluate players, lol

how many high level catching prospects do we have in the minors? Keibert Ruiz, WIll Smith, Conner Wong, Kyle Farmer, and now this kid? man guess we won't be showering Grandal with a new contract after this season. I think once Grandal is gone, Austin and Kyle will keep the seat warm for Ruiz come 2020.

Neddy wrote:how many high level catching prospects do we have in the minors? Keibert Ruiz, WIll Smith, Conner Wong, Kyle Farmer, and now this kid? man guess we won't be showering Grandal with a new contract after this season. I think once Grandal is gone, Austin and Kyle will keep the seat warm for Ruiz come 2020.

Again...

We either lose him for nothing or offer him the QO.

The QO is gonna be more for 2019 than Grandal will get in AAV on the market.
He has EVERY incentive to take the QO for his age 30 season and then sign a deal to close out his career elsewhere.

He is the catcher I like best for this team but if we were about moving on from him and **** on him in the playoffs while his wife was pregnant, we should have traded him this offseason.

I don't see him turning into a 2nd round pick.

Quake Griffin wrote:

Neddy wrote:how many high level catching prospects do we have in the minors? Keibert Ruiz, WIll Smith, Conner Wong, Kyle Farmer, and now this kid? man guess we won't be showering Grandal with a new contract after this season. I think once Grandal is gone, Austin and Kyle will keep the seat warm for Ruiz come 2020.

Again...

We either lose him for nothing or offer him the QO.

The QO is gonna be more for 2019 than Grandal will get in AAV on the market.
He has EVERY incentive to take the QO for his age 30 season and then sign a deal to close out his career elsewhere.

He is the catcher I like best for this team but if we were about moving on from him and **** on him in the playoffs while his wife was pregnant, we should have traded him this offseason.

I don't see him turning into a 2nd round pick.

ok, but what if, just say Kershaw opts out, and our FO decides to sign Machado to a mega deal, and say, we do still want to be reasonable with our lux tax, it is completely plausible to see our FO wanting to avoid offering a QO, and would rather roll with a pair of guys not named Grandal.

not that I am hating on Yaz. I love the player and the dude as well. but being real man. if the choice at this point with our pitching staff built to what it is now which is pretty stacked with youth, if the choice is machado in his 6-7 prime years vs Kershaw's aging 5-6 years plus 1 more year of Grandal, well.

this is of course a moot point if the dodgers sign everyone, or as you pointed out before, if Clayton does not opt out at all.

Neddy wrote:

Quake Griffin wrote:

Neddy wrote:how many high level catching prospects do we have in the minors? Keibert Ruiz, WIll Smith, Conner Wong, Kyle Farmer, and now this kid? man guess we won't be showering Grandal with a new contract after this season. I think once Grandal is gone, Austin and Kyle will keep the seat warm for Ruiz come 2020.

Again...

We either lose him for nothing or offer him the QO.

The QO is gonna be more for 2019 than Grandal will get in AAV on the market.
He has EVERY incentive to take the QO for his age 30 season and then sign a deal to close out his career elsewhere.

He is the catcher I like best for this team but if we were about moving on from him and **** on him in the playoffs while his wife was pregnant, we should have traded him this offseason.

I don't see him turning into a 2nd round pick.

ok, but what if, just say Kershaw opts out, and our FO decides to sign Machado to a mega deal, and say, we do still want to be reasonable with our lux tax, it is completely plausible to see our FO wanting to avoid offering a QO, and would rather roll with a pair of guys not named Grandal.

not that I am hating on Yaz. I love the player and the dude as well. but being real man. if the choice at this point with our pitching staff built to what it is now which is pretty stacked with youth, if the choice is machado in his 6-7 prime years vs Kershaw's aging 5-6 years plus 1 more year of Grandal, well.

this is of course a moot point if the dodgers sign everyone, or as you pointed out before, if Clayton does not opt out at all.

Hopefully Kershaw opts out and signs with Texas. A team will give us a pick for him if he ends up opting out.

I'd rather give Yas the QO. I think he's the best catcher we have and I'd rather have him be the bridge to Keibert/ Will Smith OR lose him for a 2nd rounder than just lose him for nothing.

So hopefully the idea is Manny re-signs and Yaz is offered the QO.

Then we can officially start building the team around the 1990s babies: Taylor (hopefully an extension that eats up his early 30s), Seager, Bellinger (jury is still out on him as a hitter but versatile defense + power), Buehler, Strip, Manny, and the last of Jansen (an 80s baby)...and we can stop worrying about basing our postseason runs around 22 and whether he should pitch on 3 days rest and whether Roberts screwed up by not starting him in a Game 7 etc. etc.

The mid 90s babies are carrying us to our 1st WS since 1988.
This is their team.

Quake Griffin wrote:

Neddy wrote:

Quake Griffin wrote:Again...

We either lose him for nothing or offer him the QO.

The QO is gonna be more for 2019 than Grandal will get in AAV on the market.
He has EVERY incentive to take the QO for his age 30 season and then sign a deal to close out his career elsewhere.

He is the catcher I like best for this team but if we were about moving on from him and **** on him in the playoffs while his wife was pregnant, we should have traded him this offseason.

I don't see him turning into a 2nd round pick.

ok, but what if, just say Kershaw opts out, and our FO decides to sign Machado to a mega deal, and say, we do still want to be reasonable with our lux tax, it is completely plausible to see our FO wanting to avoid offering a QO, and would rather roll with a pair of guys not named Grandal.

not that I am hating on Yaz. I love the player and the dude as well. but being real man. if the choice at this point with our pitching staff built to what it is now which is pretty stacked with youth, if the choice is machado in his 6-7 prime years vs Kershaw's aging 5-6 years plus 1 more year of Grandal, well.

this is of course a moot point if the dodgers sign everyone, or as you pointed out before, if Clayton does not opt out at all.

Hopefully Kershaw opts out and signs with Texas. A team will give us a pick for him if he ends up opting out.

I'd rather give Yas the QO. I think he's the best catcher we have and I'd rather have him be the bridge to Keibert/ Will Smith OR lose him for a 2nd rounder than just lose him for nothing.

So hopefully the idea is Manny re-signs and Yaz is offered the QO.

Then we can officially start building the team around the 1990s babies: Taylor (hopefully an extension that eats up his early 30s), Seager, Bellinger (jury is still out on him as a hitter but versatile defense + power), Buehler, Strip, Manny, and the last of Jansen (an 80s baby)...and we can stop worrying about basing our postseason runs around 22 and whether he should pitch on 3 days rest and whether Roberts screwed up by not starting him in a Game 7 etc. etc.

The mid 90s babies are carrying us to our 1st WS since 1988.
This is their team.

if we are gonna keep Machado and Seager, and we are running with the 90s babies, then do you agree the next one to be traded should be Turner?

No hard and fast rules. So I could see trading him given his age.

But if you're asking if I have some objection to him being on the team while the young guys take over? The answer is no. He's been a solid contributor, shows up in the playoffs, and his performance (up or down) isn't a huge story/ burden on the team/ fan base.

He can stay as long as he wants imo....until he retires preferably if the right team doesn't offer us something for him.
One of my favorite Dodgers.