thebuzzardman wrote:Since Thibs is a mediocre loser who elevates nothing and his ability to f*ck up as a front office executive is well documented from his time in Minnesota, and Leon Rose is a pastrami eating clown who leaves basketball decisions to others, who is the architect of of the current Knick team, whose vision are we seeing in system\player acquisition?
Because the Knicks certainly have "types" when it comes to role players.
I get that because Brunson is so good, he's elevating the role players, and Brunson has ties to both Leon and Thibs, and it's possible that him being on the team and making it so good is a combination of scouting, type, and possibly luck revolving around CAA ties etc.
But deciding to add the Villanova cats, with their tenacity and commitment to winning above stats etc, adding a tough passing center in iHart who is an excellent fit with them, dealing out real young talent in RJ and IQ for a perfectly fitting piece in OG, keeping McBride over Grimes, the theoretical benefit of Bogs being added, all this is someone's vision.
Aller is supposed to the capologist, the money guy, the valuation guy. That's in support of the vision.
Perrin is supposed to be the college scouting guru. Is he providing input on the pro level? Is he the main driver of which players are acquired?
Zanin, occasionally maligned on here, is pro player scouting. Is this his work?
Is it Rosas? We know he advocated for iHart. Strong pimp hand for a consultant if this is all him.
Is it Thibs, with the main vision, as the executives in the front office dance for this puppet master?
Excellent work for Mr Mediocrity, so called.
Or is it all the result of a committee? Seems unlikely based on anyone's experience working on committees
STATE YOUR CASE. SOMEONE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS.
Wrote an essay to make you happy since you had to go ALL CAPS!!! LOL
In the complex and highly competitive world of NBA basketball, attributing a team's success to a single individual oversimplifies the intricate dynamics at play. The New York Knicks' resurgence is a prime example of a multifaceted achievement, built on the collective efforts of players, coaching staff, and front office executives. It's essential to recognize that in such a team-oriented sport, success is rarely the product of one person's vision or effort.
First and foremost, the players on the court, including stars and role players alike, are the ones executing strategies and making the plays that lead to wins. Jalen Brunson's outstanding performances certainly elevate the team, but his success, and by extension the team's, hinges on the synergy with his teammates, including the tenacity of the Villanova alumni and the strategic fit of players like iHart and OG. This chemistry doesn't happen by accident; it's cultivated through careful player selection and development. Also players are learning how to play this way for the first time and it is contagious.
The coaching staff, led by Tom Thibodeau, plays a pivotal role in developing game plans, fostering player development, and creating an environment where players can thrive. While opinions on Thibodeau's coaching style may vary, the improvement in team performance and player development under his tenure is tangible. Coaches extract the best out of their rosters, adapting strategies to maximize each player's strengths and mitigate weaknesses. Thibs does a great job of finding people like Duece who fit his architect of a player.
Behind the scenes, the front office, including Leon Rose and others, work on assembling a team that fits a coherent vision. This involves scouting, drafting, trades, and managing contracts—a complex puzzle requiring insight, foresight, and a bit of luck. The acquisitions of key players and the decision to prioritize certain attributes in players reflect a strategic approach to team building. Brock Aller's financial acumen and Walt Perrin's scouting expertise, along with contributions from others like Gersson Rosas, underline the collective effort involved in shaping the roster.
Furthermore, the success of any NBA team is also supported by an extensive team of analysts, trainers, scouts, and support staff, each contributing in their own unique ways to the team's achievements.
In summary, while it's tempting to search for a singular architect behind the Knicks' success, the reality is far more complex. It's the result of strategic planning, collaborative effort, and the shared vision of many individuals within the organization. Recognizing the contributions of each member, from the front office to the bench, offers a more nuanced and accurate picture of how success is built in the NBA.
This is not done by accident but through a clear strategic plan and vision which the New York Knickerbockers have done.
? Next time Thibs won't have Julius,IQ and Brunson step in the wrong direction... Also those Bulls teams not making the finals had more to do with Rose having his knee blow up 3 years into his career...If you want to blame Thibs for that go ahead... but it's probably not rooted in any sports science fact just FYI.
