I think everyone should take a look at that page. It will clear up a lot.
I could see some people saying he shoots too many jumpshots. 60% of his attempts are two pointers. But he is in the same league as Nowitzki(74%), Mcdyess(74%),Garnett (71%),Brand (70%), West (68%), Gooden (65%), Aldridge (63%), Ilgauskas (60%), Dunacan (57%). Maybe we don't realize that these two pointers ARE a power forwards game.
Going inside 35% of his attempts he is in the same area as Ilgauskas (35%), Lebron James (36%), Aldridge (34%), Duncan (42%) and Stoudemire (45%).
Lets add that other than a coupel of these guys, no one gets the consisten double team like CB4 which clogs the lane for him.
He is in the top 20 with 77 dunks in the season, 7th in the league with 53 and 1s and and top 20 in getting fouled. Other then Stoudemire, no one in his percenentage group of going inside gets fouled at his rate, showing how tough is it for him in there.
Maybe some of the criticism is unwarranted?