Optms wrote:Its an idea. Not the best trade offer they can receive for Butler but most certainly the best from Toronto without including Bosh in the mix. Keep in mind this is the same team that turned down the acquisition for Stoudemire because Butler was asked to be included. Look how that's turned out for Washington. Think most fans wish they could go back and re-do that?
I don't wish we redid that actually. We'd be a bad team with an expiring Amare and I wouldn't want us to try and resign him. That dude is a risky free agent signing due to injuries and 'the Phoenix Effect'; great talent but i wouldn't touch him with a max contract coming. He's great flashing to the basket, but not everyone can hit him on those like Steve Nash.
Optms wrote:As for Bargnani, Washington would get a younger player back who can score from the perimeter and could probably benefit from Flip's system. I highly doubt Haywood resigns with this team so getting back a lock of a center to play there next season with McGee backing him up wouldn't be so bad rather than getting nothing for Haywood. Or perhaps play him at the 4 and bring Jamison off the bench as his game improves and AJ's game declines. Or better yet, move AJ to the 3. Washington's offense isn't exactly stellar as most thought it would be also so they could use the scoring. I don't know if you've watched DeRozan play but he already is just as good and probably even better then Nick Young will ever be. The guy has the tools to be a pretty decent defender and a good 16 to 20 ppg scorer in a couple years. Nick Young's basketball IQ is laughable. His defense is pathetic and placing bets on his confidence to determine whether he'll have a good game is pretty sad. Like I've mentioned, though. Just an idea with some potential star players coming back to Washington and most noticeably some change. This Washington club looks a mess right now, and I don't see how this could be any worse then what has already transacted here in the early NBA season for this club.
Edit: I doubt Toronto does this deal but that team is also a big mess. Bosh and AB don't really compliment each other's game. It's a stretch if they really covet Butler as much as we would believe.
No question that your deal has a lot of value coming back (too much from Toronto's perspective), but it's just a bad fit as Hermit mentioned due to certain similarities between our Young Bigs and Andrea; not to mention Haywood would be a step closer to leaving town.
Honestly, if we have a front court tandem of Blatche and Mcgee, we need to complement them with a hard-fouling mud-dog, not the Italian version of a boy named Sue (and i say that from the perspective of one who likes his game). We would be cataclysmic on the boards with those three guys. And we'd be locking into a really big and really long contract.
Young has shown a lot of growth of late. He's just some good habits away from being a fairly decent starter. If we need to upgrade there though, you can hardly go into a draft without tripping over 2-guards. The idea of developing DeRozen and Young at the same time is not sounding real good. So if Young's not the guy, better we get started on a new scoring guard after that's already been made clear.
Our talent would theoretically upgrade, but we would have an even more confused lineup than we do already.