Right now and for the future, Brandon Roy or T-Mac?

[kd35sneighbor]

Who ya got?

And if it's Roy, then doesn't that make him a top tier shooting guard since T-Mac isn't so far off from being top tier?

[hermes]

roy

because he is younger and isn't made of glass

[NetsForce]

Here's the thing I would take Roy because he's healthier even if he himself is not the picture of perfect health, but that doesn't mean he's better than T-Mac. I mean when you stop and realize that Roy is on his rookie contract you basically have to take him over T-Mac, T-Mac is the better player than Roy the problem is that he's almost never healthy anymore.

[EiRON]

Roy, because there is no future for Tracy McGrady

[Patterns]

I'd take TMac now no doubt.

Roy will never be as good as TMac but if you consider the future/injuries then you gotta take Roy because he's younger and more durable.

[jeremy1215]

Roy

[Milkdud]

kind of a funny poll, I don't see how would couldn't take Roy give injuries, contract and age.

[mudyez]

now: tmac
future: roy