RealGM

Player of the decade

1. Kobe
2. Lebron
3. Shaq
4. Duncan
5. Nash
6. Garnett

He only got something like 3% of the fans votes. That is truly pathetic, he is no worse than the 4th best player of the decade.

No, Duncan got disrespected. He should be no lower than 2.

Fans are idiots though, so I'm not surprised.

No, King James got disrespected. He should be 1!

If shaq retired two years ago HE probably wouldn't have been disrespected. But then again he's been acting like a real turd that last two years.

Part of the reason Kobe is number 1 is because he has four rings - equal to that of Shaq and Duncan.

However Shaq was the main reason why he got 3, so I can't understand why he would be above Shaq. However due to Shaq's decline over the last 3yrs then a fair argument can be made.

Yeah, I saw that earlier. Nash, really?

Garnett for the decade has:

Championship
MVP
DPOY
8-time all-NBA
10-time all-defensive team
10 allstar selctions (1 all-star MVP)

Lead the league in rebounding 4 consecutive seasons.

That's a near perfect decade..

It's the classic case of "What have you done for me lately?" when it comes to these things.

Had the survey been done after the championship season he would have probably been up there with Kobe and LeBron.

Speaking of LeBron.....he hasn't even been here for the whole decade but he's #2?

TA42 wrote:It's the classic case of "What have you done for me lately?" when it comes to these things.

Had the survey been done after the championship season he would have probably been up there with Kobe and LeBron.

Speaking of LeBron.....he hasn't even been here for the whole decade but he's #2?

Those casual NBA fans don't know a lick about the history of the game.

IMO,

1. Duncan
2. Shaq
3. Kobe
4. Garnett

The rest don't matter.

KG should only be 4th or 5th on the list. I agree that Lebron shouldn't be so high, but its a fan vote not an actual award. Lebron should be last on the list.

1. Shaq
2. Kobe
3. Duncan
4. KG or Nash
5. KG or Nash
6. Lebron

1. Duncan
2. Kobe
3. Shaq
4. Garnett
5. Nash
6. LeBron

LanFill wrote:1. Duncan
2. Kobe
3. Shaq
4. Garnett
5. Nash
6. LeBron

That's my list, too.

I think you put Shaq and Kobe ahead of Duncan because they've won back to backs. Timmy's four either came 4 yrs apart or every other year.

the fans voted AI and almost mcgrady to the all star game

T-Mac United wrote:
Those casual NBA fans don't know a lick about the history of the game.

IMO,

1. Duncan
2. Shaq
3. Kobe
4. Garnett

The rest don't matter.

This is my sentiment....you could switch duncan and shaq though. in no way should kobe be above shaq or duncan....

perfectblack999 wrote:

T-Mac United wrote:
Those casual NBA fans don't know a lick about the history of the game.

IMO,

1. Duncan
2. Shaq
3. Kobe
4. Garnett

The rest don't matter.

This is my sentiment....you could switch duncan and shaq though. in no way should kobe be above shaq or duncan....

I agree. Kobe is a great player, but Shaq and Duncan are the guys who really dominated the decade. Kobe was always Shaq's second fiddle. Duncan was the best player on all of his championship teams. Honestly, it simply comes down to people not really understanding the game of basketball, IMO. Shaq and Duncan weren't just marginally better than Kobe. They were MUCH better.

PS. LeBron is so much better than Kobe it is scary. Would I take Kobe over LeBron for a final shot? Sure. The thing is that LeBron is much more dominant over all of the preceding possessions in a game.

If AI and TMAC being voted as starters weren't reason enough to stop letting fans vote for things....this should send a freakin alarm that fans aren't wise enough to vote on things.

there's no way KG should be behind Nash and lebron. if it werent for the lakers winning last year, KG should be 3rd behind duncan and shaq.

shaq freakin averaged over 40 ppg (or close to it) for an entire nba finals. he carried those lakers teams, and kobe with it.

i was extremely pissed to see KG be last. and he also got last in his two categories he was nominated in; best playoff performance (2004 semis, game 7. he had 32 pts, 21 rebs, 5 blk, 4 stl, 5-6 ast, including numerous clutch plays) and best defensive perfomance (same game, with 2 steals and 2 GW blocks in the last min and a half). KG finished LAST in those categories too.

fans are idiots.

I guess Kobe had a case here but it should at least have been close. I mean he received more than 50 % of the votes. It's just ridiculous!

1. Kobe
2. Duncan
3. Shaq
4. Garnett
5. Lebron
6. Nash

how many did horry win this decade?

To be fair, before he became a Celtic, and discounting that fanastic MVP season he had, KG was stuck on teams that would lose annually in the 1st round.