Which defensman would you choose

[waxmonkey]

Lubomir Visnovsky
Wade Redden
Dan Boyle
Dion Phaneuf

I'm being offered a trade and would like to add one of these guys to sweeten the deal. I'm lean on defensmen, who do I go after?

[Crowned]

I'd rank them as follows...

1. Phanuef
2. Boyle (most underrated defenseman in the NHL)
3. Visnovsky
4. Redden

[ajaX82]

Redden last Crowned? Hes still pretty damn good.

EDIT: I just looked up last seasons stats, yea, i could see why you think that.

Go with Boyle or Phaneuf

[Crowned]

Redden last Crowned? Hes still pretty damn good.

EDIT: I just looked up last seasons stats, yea, i could see why you think that.

Go with Boyle or Phaneuf

Redden could have a breakout year, which is why I think Visnovsky and Redden are interchangeable...they could go either way. However, in terms of fantasy points, I'd go with Boyle and Phanuef over him.

Redden could go either way, he could very well end up being an elite defenseman fantasy wise, or repeat last season. It's tough to say, because afterall...it is fantasy hockey.

[MAS]

1. Phaneuf
2. Boyle

[TR50]

ma no mi nah, do do do doo doo...dion phaneuf do doo do doo

[Griff83]

Visnovsky is going to be a beast this year

[McFurious1]

Phaneuf